Burt's Best Interpreter (other than Dionne)
Moderator: mark
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jan 23, 2004 6:31 pm
- Location: New Orleans, Louisiana, USA
- Contact:
Burt's Best Interpreter (other than Dionne)
Who do you think is the best interpreter of Bacharach songs? Feel free to post your own favorites if I've left them off this highly subjective, thoroughly incomplete list...
-
- Posts: 788
- Joined: Thu Feb 19, 2004 12:45 pm
- Location: Staten Island N.Y.
other then Dionne
My favorites are Dusty Springfield,Lou Jonhson,Luther Vandross
other than dionne
male: Bobby Vinton
After i heard the song Charlie
nearly 30 years ago, it knocked me
out. This rare gem should receive
more recognition.
And Bobby's earlier hit "Blue
on Blue" was a pleasant enough song
but nowhere near this song Charlie.
female: can't find anyone who
could match Dionne. But marginally,
let's say Astrud Gilberto. Her
voice just fits Burt's song.
By the way, i heard her version
of "Wanting Things" years ago, and
it was SUPERB. How i like to hear it again ! Anyone who have heard her version got any comments on
Gilberto ?
After i heard the song Charlie
nearly 30 years ago, it knocked me
out. This rare gem should receive
more recognition.
And Bobby's earlier hit "Blue
on Blue" was a pleasant enough song
but nowhere near this song Charlie.
female: can't find anyone who
could match Dionne. But marginally,
let's say Astrud Gilberto. Her
voice just fits Burt's song.
By the way, i heard her version
of "Wanting Things" years ago, and
it was SUPERB. How i like to hear it again ! Anyone who have heard her version got any comments on
Gilberto ?
-
- Posts: 1194
- Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2004 11:14 pm
I voted for Dusty Springfield, but B.J. Thomas is just as good. The three songs he sang, "Raindrops", "Everybody's Out of Town" and "Long Ago, Tomorrow" were spectacular. I think it's a big shame that Burt & Hal didn't give many more original songs to B.J. Thomas. One of the great male pop voices of all time, IMHO.
By the way, from what I understand from a friend's personal conversation with B.J., B.J. didn't particularly enjoy working with Burt. Burt was too demanding of him.
By the way, from what I understand from a friend's personal conversation with B.J., B.J. didn't particularly enjoy working with Burt. Burt was too demanding of him.
I have very little opinion regarding this question other than outside of Dionne...I think Dusty and Lou Johnson, clearly had the feel of the music. Regarding BJ Thomas, I agree with Enormous's friend, after reading many of the Burt bio's it's clear that Burt is perfecting and demanding. And BJ has even acknowledged that Burt wanted him to learn how to read music, at which BJ basically refused. And as well BJ was also was enjoying the 'evils of drugs, drinks, and women' as well as touring lots and did not enjoy the rigors of being in the studio with someone as taxing as Burt!!
Mark:
You really opened up a "can of worms" with this question! I think about this every time I hear a BB song performed by anyone other than Burt or Dionne. I agree with many of the posts responding so far - I'm a real Dusty fan; however, the only Dusty interpretations that I consider "definitive" are "Wishing And Hopin" & "Look Of Love" (maybe "I Just Don't Know What To Do With Myself") Della Reese does a great version of "House Is Not A Home" and Jackie DeShannon has done some beautiful interpretations in addition to her blockbuster version of "What The World Needs Now"
Patti LaBelle has scored with "We Need A Little Faith" and "Sleep With Me Tonight" as well as "On My Own" with Michael McDonald. Same holds true for Aretha Franklin "Someone Elses Eyes" and "Everchanging Times".
I'll add to this later on
You really opened up a "can of worms" with this question! I think about this every time I hear a BB song performed by anyone other than Burt or Dionne. I agree with many of the posts responding so far - I'm a real Dusty fan; however, the only Dusty interpretations that I consider "definitive" are "Wishing And Hopin" & "Look Of Love" (maybe "I Just Don't Know What To Do With Myself") Della Reese does a great version of "House Is Not A Home" and Jackie DeShannon has done some beautiful interpretations in addition to her blockbuster version of "What The World Needs Now"
Patti LaBelle has scored with "We Need A Little Faith" and "Sleep With Me Tonight" as well as "On My Own" with Michael McDonald. Same holds true for Aretha Franklin "Someone Elses Eyes" and "Everchanging Times".
I'll add to this later on
Best Interpreter ?
I think that each performer got his/her own way of interpretation.
Do not forget that the most songs that Burt wrote with his co-writers are very demandings songs!
So my opinion is that there is no best interpreter.
Sorry !
Do not forget that the most songs that Burt wrote with his co-writers are very demandings songs!
So my opinion is that there is no best interpreter.
Sorry !