http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/music_b ... gress.html
But, since no one "who really matters" reads headlines or watches award shows anymore... (Kidding reference to the other thread on the subject.)
Do we need anyone to validate what we think about Burt or Hal? No. What else is new, except that maybe some of us seem to care about precisely who agrees with them?
Can awards in general help create mistaken perceptions about who is or isn't worth paying attention to? I certainly think so.
Can we put an end to awards that grossly misrepresent, in our opinion, the quality of the artists who receive or don't receive them? We certainly can't. Thanks G-d for that! What we can do is to complain about them if we wish --as I have done.
In my opinion, we should be rejoicing at the fact that, despite all the issues with most or all awards and award shows, this specific prize is tied to two of the greatest names in music history (a good choice to begin with) and to an iconic institution (that not by accident houses the Gershwings' works) -- and is being offered to Burt and Hal at a relatively early stage in the life of the award. Indeed, maybe its first edition didn't mean as much, and names like Paul Simon, Stevie Wonder and Paul McCartney may help some people appreciate Burt and Hal more than if these two giants had received, say, the first or the second edition of the prize. So if I were in charge, maybe I would have set it up precisely this way. (OK. Maybe I would have had only one edition of the Gershwin Prize.)
Since receiving an early edition of this prize doesn't seem to question the wisdom of the giver, I welcome the additional exposure. I know of no one more deserving of an even wider (and deeper) audience or of an audience that deserves anything better.
I see no need to attempt to blemish this award -- now, at least -- with whatever resentments we may have relative to other awards.
I think I can relate to just about everything that was said by all of you. I just tried to spell out my pespective, which seems closer to the one expressed by Ron. Maybe it will be helpful to those who aren't sharing our joy.
Let's hope that Burt and Hal are glad and are going to be happy about how it all turns out.